Maricopa County, Arizona Election Employees Election Fraud
Newly released video shows Maricopa County recorder employees entering the county elections department and leaving with a pre-tabulation ballot scanner and provisional ballot envelopes during Tempe’s jurisdictional elections earlier this year. A special prosecutor is currently investigating whether Brian Colby, the chief information officer for Maricopa County recorder Justin Heap, and another unidentified recorder’s office worker broke the law by removing the items.
Incident Occurred Early March 2026 Tempe City Council
The incident occurred as votes were being tallied in the March 10th election for three seats on the Tempe City Council. According to emails Phoenix New Times received in response to a public records request, the ballot scanner was used during that election.
Video Footage INSIDE of Maricopa County Tabulation and Election Center
Silent security camera footage from inside the Maricopa County tabulation and election center shows Colby and a second recorder’s office employee pushing a two-tiered gray cart through a cubicle area. According to an HR fraud investigation, an election employee asked them what they were doing. In response, Colby told her that recorder’s office election director Ray Valenzuela knows about it. The election employee said she wasn’t informed that the ballot scanner would be removed. A minute later, Colby walked towards the early voting processing cage in the facility. An unidentified election employee opened the cage for him and Colby grabbed what appears to be Maricopa County provisional ballot affidavit envelopes according to the HR election fraud investigation.
The election fraud investigation couldn’t locate video evidence of Colby returning the ballot envelopes to the cage, but it did confirm with the elections department that they were ultimately accounted for. The Maricopa County election fraud investigation alleged that these ballot envelopes may have been photocopied, which raises questions and risks for the county regarding election processes.
Video Footage OUTSIDE of Maricopa County Tabulation and Election Center
Minutes after Colby left the cage, an outside camera recorded him and the other employee leaving the northeast side of the building via a ramp with the ballot scanner on 3rd Avenue. A different camera captured them pushing it toward a gray pickup truck with a black cover. According to an HR election fraud investigation, the truck had no county insignia and was presumably a personal vehicle. Colby opened the truck bed and appeared to place the ballot envelopes on the front seat of the vehicle. The two men then slid the ballot scanner into the truck bed and closed the tailgate. A minute later, after the second employee returned the cart to MTAC, the pair drove away. Due to chain of custody issues, the board replaced the ballot scanner at a cost of $7,000. A purchase order shows the election department bought the ballot scanner from Runbeck Election Services in January 2023 for $105,000.
